| Year | Class | Champion | Runner-up |
| 1995 | Major | Wallen Construction, Bean Station, TX | DCS Tigers, Pompano Beach, FL |
| 1995 | A | Air Touch Paving, Atlanta, GA | Jenkin’s Motors, Union City, TN |
| 1996 | Major | N/A | N/A |
| 1997 | Major | Tighe Club, Wilmington, MA | N/A |
| 1998 | Major | Silver Lido Cafe/Metalplex, Phil., PA | Tighe Club, Wilmington, MA |
| 1998 | 10 | Kodiak Landscaping, Butler, NJ | Paskas Funeral Home, Rutherford, NJ |
| 1999 | Major | Texas Liquids/AE, Staten Island, NY | Rupperts, Riverdale, NJ |
| 2000 | Major | Tighe Club, Wilmington, MA | Texas Liquids/All Energy, Staten Island, NY |
| 2001 | Major | Globe Softball, Red Bank, NJ | Bonnell’s/Team Hardinger, Erie, PA |
| 2002 | Major | – Not Held |
Tournament discontinued in 2003.
