All Time MVP – Brenda Smith Foster
- P – Judy Hedgecock (11)
- P – Charlotte Cates (10)
- P – Jennifer “Sis” Woods (10)
- C – Jen Harp Oliver (7)
- 1B – Princess Carpenter (5)
- 2B – Brenda Smith Foster (13)
- 3B – Nancy Oldham (11)
- SS – Ida Jean Hopkins (11)
- OF – Carol Bemis (10)
- OF – Linda Garbett (9)
- OF – Donna Wolfe (8)
- OF – Alberta Kohl Sims (7)
- OF – Norma Eschebrenner Ante (6)
- Util – Sue Bupp Iyles (12)
- Util – Linda Polley (11)
- Util – Carol Lewis (10)
- Util – Carol Perroz (10)
- Util – Jody Trimmer (10)
- Util – Sherri Pickard (9)
- Util – Cheryl Trapnell (9)
Honorable Mention:
- Barb Balestrinos (8)
- Kathy Riley (8)
- Chris Padgett (7)
- Sherri France (7)
- Diane Hatch (7)
- Marsha Repogle Ehler (6)
- Marilyn Busse (6)
- Trina Hertzog (6)
- Linda Garbett (6)
- Tiffany Daniels (7)
- Sandy Edwards (6)
- Heather Carr (6)
- Sherri Nidiffer (6)
- Gina Green (6)
- Theresa Held (6)
- Lorraine Hudson (6)
- Dot Bailey (5)
- Myra Williams (5)
- Karen Baker (5)
- Lisa Lines (5)
NOTE: Missing the COMPLETE ASA All-American Teams from 1980, 81, 82 & 96. Will Update when received
