| Year | Class | Champion | Runner-up | MVP |
| 1984 | Major | Alibi Inn, Staten Island, NY | Juris Doctorettes, Spokane, WA | Sue Harms, Alibi Inn |
| 1985 | Major | Alibi Inn, Staten Island, NY | Stan-Mill Mitts, Vestal, NY | Lisa DiRenzo, Alibi Inn |
| 1986 | Major | Zerbo’s Hellbenders, Staten Island, NY | Lilac City Merchants, Spokane, WA | Joan Mercola, Hellbenders |
| 1987 | Major | Talk of the Town, Staten Island, NY | Kulick’s Market, Keene, NH | Betty Costello, Talk of the Town |
| 1988 | Major | Dennis’ Islanders, Staten Island, NY | Kulick’s Market, Keene, NH | Betty Costello, Dennis’ Islanders |
| 1989 | Major | Kulick’s Market, Keene, NH | Dennis’ Islanders, Staten Island, NY | N/A |
| 1990 | Major | Dennis’ Islanders, Staten Island, NY | Portuguese American Club, Lawrence, MA | Jennifer Albrizio, Dennis’ Islanders |
| 1991 | Major | The House That Jack Built, Buffalo, NY | Portuguese American Club, Lawrence, MA | N/A |
| 1991 | A | Baloon Saloon, Brooklyn, NY | Thunderbolts, Keene, NH | N/A |
| 1992 | Major | Guaynabo Mets, Guaynabo, Puerto Rico | PA Club, Methuen, MA | July Curbelo, Mets |
| 1993 | Major | PA Club, Methuen, MA | Stan-Mill Mitts, Vestal, NY | Shonda Baker, PA Club |
| 1994 | Major | Mike’s Famous Hot Dogs, Waterford, NY | PA Club, Methuen, MA | Theresa McKinnon, Mike’s |
| 1995 | Major | Roger’s Renegades, Hookset, NH | PA Club, Methuen, MA | Nicole Hebert, Roger’s Renegades |
| 1996 | Major | Thunderbolts, Keene, NH | Stan-Mill Mitts, Vestal, NY | N/A |
| 1997 | Major | Thunderbolts, Keene, NH | Stadium Sportswear, Mead, WA | N/A |
| 1998 | Major | Stadium Sportswear, Mead, WA | Stan-Mill Mitts, Vestal, NY | Kathy White, Stadium |
| 1999 | Major | Stadium Sportswear, Mead, WA | Julie’s, New York, NY | N/A |
| 2000 | Major | Roger’s Renegades, Hookset, NH | Stadium Sportswear, Mead, WA | N/A |
| 2001 | Major | Roger’s Renegades, Hookset, NH | Big Dawgs, Erie, PA | Nicole Adamson, Renegades |
| 2002 | Major | Viper Sportswear, Spokane, WA | Roger’s Renegades, Hookset, NH | N/A |
| 2003 | Major | Cancelled | ||
| 2004 | Open | Cancelled | ||
| 2005 | Open | Wild Bunch, Beaverton, OR | Red Heat, Hillsboro, OR | Sarah Jarrett, Wild Bunch |
| 2006 | Open | Cancelled |
Tournament discontinued after the 2007 season.
