| Year | Class | Champion | Runner-up |
| 2002 | A | L&P/Kaytes/LPP, Staten Island, NY | Bonnell’s, Erie, PA |
| 2002 | B | Fanelli’s, Staten Island, NY | N/A |
| 2003 | A | Westminster CRT, Westminster, MD | L&P/Kaytes/Rolaids, Staten Island, NY |
| 2003 | B | Easton Steel, Easton, MD | N/A |
| 2004 | A | Patsy’s, Massapequa, NY | Globe Softball, Red Bank, NJ |
| 2004 | B | Easton Steel, Easton, MD | N/A |
| 2005 | A | NY Gremlins, Staten Island, NY | Patsy’s, Massapequa, NY |
| 2005 | B | Willow Street Tire, Lancaster, PA | N/A |
| 2006 | A | NY Gremlins, Clifton Park, NY | Adco/Tool Shed, Staten Island, NY |
| 2006 | 10 | Easton Steel, Easton, MD | Joe’s Lobster House, Staten Island, NY |
| 2007 | A | Zubi’s, Port Jervis, NY | L&P Tree Service, Staten Island, NY |
| 2008 | A | Swashbucklers, Staten Island, NY | L&P Tree Service, Staten Island, NY |
| 2009 | N/A | N/A |
